
Toast the Pepper:
Warm the cracked pepper briefly so it becomes fragrant.

Reduce the wine-shallot mixture almost dry so it folds into the butter without weeping. On a hot steak, a thin slice melts into something like a glossy pan sauce.
Red wine shallot butter should taste like the last spoonful of a steakhouse pan sauce, but in sliceable butter form. The important move is reducing the wine mixture until it is almost dry before it ever touches the softened butter. If the wine base is loose, the butter will weep. If it is thick, glossy, and cooled completely, it folds into the butter cleanly and melts over steak, pork chops, burgers, mushrooms, potatoes, and vegetables like it belongs there.

Warm the cracked pepper briefly so it becomes fragrant.

Soften the shallots in butter, then add garlic.


Add vinegar, red wine, honey, and herbs, then cook until almost dry.

Chill the reduction until it is fully cool before mixing.

Fold the cooled red wine shallots into softened butter with herbs.


Roll into a log, refrigerate until firm, and slice as needed.

Reduce the wine-shallot mixture almost dry so it folds into the butter without weeping. On a hot steak, a thin slice melts into something like a glossy pan sauce.
About 1¼ cups red wine shallot compound butter — Serving size: 1 tablespoon

Bring The Butter Club to your table for a private dinner, cooking class, or meal at a vacation rental.
Tell Me About Your EventLoading approved reviews…
Send ingredient, instruction, or correction questions to the recipe inbox.