Baking Recipes | Good Buddy Butter Club

Pastry dough, butter, stone fruit, and a baking tray beside a warm oven

Hot baked artichoke dip with Parmesan, tomato, and golden edges in a brown ceramic baking dish, served with crackers and toasted bread.

Artichoke Dip

Baked white fish fillets with tender rice, spinach, tomato, onion, and dried basil in a rectangular casserole dish.

Baked Fish and Rice with Spinach

1 hr 15 minEasy

Four baked tomato halves topped with buttery bread, parsley, and Parmesan in a vintage floral baking dish.

Baked Tomato Halves

Sliced barbecue-glazed meatloaf on a floral platter with mashed potatoes, carrots, and baked beans in the background.

BBQ Meatloaf

1 hr 40 minEasy

Plated serving of Beef Noodle Casserole with wide egg noodles, creamy cottage cheese filling, tomato-beef sauce, and sliced mushrooms on vintage floral dinnerware.

Beef Noodle Casserole

About 1 hour 30 minutesMedium

Thick slice of Betty’s baked lasagna with beef-and-pork tomato sauce, herbed cottage-cheese filling, and golden melted mozzarella on a vintage plate.

Betty’s Baked Lasagna

About 2 hours 50 minutesMedium

Walnut banana bread with a deep golden crust, sliced on a wooden cutting board beside ripe bananas and vintage floral kitchen linens.

Betty’s Banana Bread

About 2 hours 30 minutesEasy

Whole pavlova topped with whipped cream, raspberries, blueberries, and strawberries on a vintage plate beside a cup of coffee.

Betty’s Pavlova

Warm peach cobbler with golden pancake-mix topping and vanilla ice cream, with the baking dish behind it.

Betty’s Peach Cobbler

A square serving of Betty’s zucchini lasagna with tender zucchini layers, creamy cottage cheese, savory meat sauce, and browned mozzarella.

Betty’s Zucchini Lasagna

1 hr 15 minEasy

Blueberry cheesecake bar with a graham cracker crust and glossy blueberry topping, served with whipped cream and fresh blueberries.

Blueberry Cheesecake Bars

About 10 hoursMedium

Warm blueberry cobbler with golden spoon-dropped topping in a vintage ceramic baking dish, served with vanilla ice cream.

Blueberry Cobbler

Sliced boiled raisin cake with walnuts and raisins on a wooden board beside a cup of coffee.

Boiled Raisin Cake

Creamy broccoli rice casserole baked until bubbling and golden in a rectangular vintage ceramic baking dish.

Broccoli Rice Casserole

1 hr 20 minEasy

Two tomato-sauced cabbage rolls on a plate, one cut open to show the beef-and-rice filling, with sour cream on the side.

Cabbage Rolls

2 hr 15 minMedium

Red-and-white candy cane twist cookies arranged on a vintage holly-patterned Christmas platter.

Candy Cane Twist Cookies

1 hr 30 minEasy

Baked celery almondine in a vintage brown-rimmed casserole dish with creamy sauce, toasted almonds, Parmesan, and golden breadcrumbs.

Celery Almondine

Two baked halves of Cheesy French Bread topped with melted cheese and scallions on a vintage baking sheet.

Cheesy French Bread

Cheesy ham and rice casserole with peas, melted cheddar, and a golden breadcrumb topping in a cream floral baking dish.

Cheesy Ham & Rice Bake

Warm cherry cobbler pudding cake with golden cake over bubbling tart cherries in a vintage floral baking dish, with vanilla ice cream nearby.

Cherry Cobbler Pudding Cake

1 hr 15 minEasy

Warm Cherry Rhubarb Crunch in a vintage baking dish with a serving on a plate and vanilla ice cream.

Cherry Rhubarb Crunch

1 hr 20 minEasy

Four browned chicken breasts over creamy mushroom rice with sliced mushrooms in a glass baking dish, served with green beans.

Chicken & Cream of Mushroom Rice Bake

Baked chicken breasts and broccoli covered in creamy cheddar-beer rarebit sauce in a vintage casserole dish.

Chicken Rarebit

About 1 hour 10 minutesEasy

Four baked chicken breasts topped with whole green chiles and melted Monterey Jack in a glossy jalapeño glaze, with pan sauce being spooned over the top.

Chili-Cheese Chicken

Chocolate cherry cupcakes topped with chocolate buttercream on a wire rack, with one cupcake cut open to reveal the cherry center.

Chocolate Cherry Cupcakes

1 hr 25 minEasy

Chocolate chip cheesecake with a deep cocoa crumb crust, one slice removed, and a plated slice topped with whipped cream and chocolate shavings.

Chocolate Chip Cheesecake

Chocolate Crumble Bars cut into squares with a soft chocolate filling and chopped-nut crumble topping on a vintage platter.

Chocolate Crumble Bars

2 hr 50 minEasy

Square of cinnamon zucchini snack cake with cream cheese frosting, chopped nuts, and cinnamon beside the remaining cake in a 9x13-inch pan.

Cinnamon Zucchini Snack Cake

2 hr 10 minEasy

Classic key lime pie with a graham cracker crust, whipped cream, lime slices, and one clean slice removed.

Classic Fresh Key Lime Pie

5 hr 35 minEasy

Classic German Streusel Topping

Classic German Streusel Topping

About 1 hourEasy

A loaf of Classic Holiday Fruit Cake with three slices showing red and green candied fruit, raisins, currants, and chopped nuts on a vintage Christmas platter.

Classic Holiday Fruit Cake

About 5 hoursEasy

Classic Mexican Flan (Flan Mexicano)

Classic Mexican Flan (Flan Mexicano)

Two stuffed green pepper halves filled with seasoned ground beef and rice, topped with melted cheddar and tomato sauce on a vintage floral plate.

Classic Stuffed Green Peppers

About 1 hour 50 minutesEasy

Family-style Yorkshire pudding baked until deeply golden in a square metal pan and served with brown gravy.

Classic Yorkshire Pudding

A slice of coconut custard pie lifted from a glass pie plate, showing a creamy center and golden toasted coconut top.

Coconut Custard Pie

Golden corn casserole in a square ceramic baking dish with a serving spoon and a portion on a floral plate.

Corn Casserole

1 hr 10 minEasy

Plate of cream cheese sugar cookies cut into Christmas trees, stars, bells, and candy canes and decorated with red, green, and white sugar.

Cream Cheese Sugar Cookies

About 5 hours 35 minutesEasy

Creamed corn and oyster casserole with whole oysters and a golden saltine cracker-crumb topping in a vintage ceramic baking dish.

Creamed Corn & Oysters

Creamy celery casserole with blue cheese, green bell pepper, and browned edges in a vintage oval baking dish.

Creamy Celery Casserole

Creamy chicken and mixed vegetable casserole with a crisp golden stuffing topping, served on a plate beside the baking dish.

Creamy Chicken Stuffing Casserole

Creamy Corn & Macaroni Casserole prepared and ready to serve.

Creamy Corn & Macaroni Casserole

1 hr 10 minEasy

Creamy Poblano Pasta (Pasta Verde)

Creamy Poblano Pasta (Pasta Verde)

1 HOUR 40 MINUTESMedium

Creole haddock topped with chunky tomato and green pepper sauce, served over rice with lemon, parsley, and crusty bread.

Creole Haddock

Creamy tuna casserole with peas, roasted peanuts, and a crisp chow mein noodle topping in a vintage oval casserole dish.

Crispy Tuna Noodle Casserole

Glass baking dish of creamy hamburger casserole with mixed vegetables and a crisp ridged potato-chip topping, with one serving removed.

Crunchy Hamburger Casserole

Creamy Dorito chicken casserole topped with shredded lettuce, diced tomato, and sour cream, served with lime wedges and salsa beside a vintage floral baking dish.

Dorito Chicken Casserole

A chocolate-topped square of Double Chocolate Zucchini Cake beside the remaining cake in a vintage metal pan, with zucchini and cocoa nearby.

Double Chocolate Zucchini Cake

1 hr 30 minEasy

Thick square of frozen vanilla ice cream layered with coconut crunch and topped with glossy whole-raspberry sauce on a vintage floral table.

Frozen Raspberry Crunch

Sliced Garden Vegetable Pie with broccoli, green bell pepper, onion, and cheddar in a glass pie plate, with one wedge plated for serving.

Garden Vegetable Pie

Golden cinnamon twists with visible brown sugar and cinnamon layers piled on a vintage plate beside a cup of coffee.

Golden Cinnamon Twists

About 2 hours 30 minutesEasy

Golden Cornmeal Bundt Cake dusted with confectioners’ sugar, with one slice served beside lemon curd on a vintage patterned plate.

Golden Cornmeal Bundt Cake

2 hr 45 minEasy

Golden Pineapple Upside-Down Cake

1 hr 25 minEasy

Creamy Gum Yuk casserole with diced chicken, Chinese-style vegetables, and crisp chow mein noodles in a white baking dish.

Gum Yuk

Baked halibut portions in creamy mushroom and pea sauce with a lightly browned Parmesan topping in a vintage floral casserole dish.

Halibut with Mushrooms

A plated serving of hamburger cabbage casserole topped with melted cheese, with the casserole dish and fireplace in the background.

Hamburger Cabbage Casserole

1 hr 25 minEasy

Sliced herbed lemon meat loaf on a vintage serving platter with fresh lemon wedges.

Herbed Lemon Meat Loaf

1 hr 30 minEasy

Homemade Focaccia Croutons

Homemade Focaccia Croutons

Thick square of lasagna layered with mini meatballs, ricotta, tomato sauce, noodles, and melted mozzarella on a brown serving plate.

Lasagna with Mini Meatballs

Loaded twice-baked potato casserole with rough-mashed russet potatoes, crisp potato skins, melted cheddar, bacon, and green onions in a glass baking dish.

Loaded Twice-Baked Potato Casserole

About 2 hours 15 minutesEasy

Stacked magic cookie bars with a graham cracker crust, sweetened condensed milk, semi-sweet chocolate chips, sweetened coconut, and chopped pecans on a vintage serving plate.

Magic Cookie Bars

1 hr 45 minEasy

Maple Glazed Walnuts

Maple Glazed Walnuts

1 HOUR 5 MINUTESEasy

Slice of Millionaire’s Pie layered with chocolate chips, coconut, and pecans, served with whipped cream and caramel drizzle.

Millionaire’s Pie

3 hr 30 minEasy

Sliced molasses corn bread served with orange butter beside fresh oranges and molasses.

Molasses Corn Bread with Orange Butter

1 hr 30 minEasy

Warm slice of oatmeal cake with caramelized coconut-cinnamon frosting and optional pecans beside a cup of coffee.

Oatmeal Cake with Broiled Cinnamon Frosting

1 hr 45 minMedium

Oatmeal Raisin Granola

Oatmeal Raisin Granola

1 HOUR 30 MINUTESEasy

Large square of old-fashioned chocolate cake topped with glossy broiled coconut and chopped nuts, served beside the remaining 9x13-inch cake.

Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake

1 hr 45 minEasy

Golden onion-breaded pork chop served with mashed potatoes and green beans on a vintage cream-and-gold dinner plate.

Onion-Baked Pork Chops

Glazed orange Bundt cake with golden raisins and pecans, with one slice cut to show the tender crumb.

Orange Bundt Cake

2 hr 15 minEasy

Golden Parmesan breadcrumb-crusted halibut with a creamy coating, served with rice, green beans, and a lemon wedge.

Parmesan Crusted Halibut

Warm Peach Crumble Pie with a golden crumble topping served with vanilla ice cream and whipped cream.

Peach Crumble Pie

1 hr 20 minEasy

Peach-glazed pork chop served with warm peach halves and a glossy sweet-tangy sauce on a vintage plate.

Peach Glazed Pork Chops

Picadillo-stuffed poblano pepper over tomato caldillo

Picadillo-Stuffed Poblano Peppers (Chiles Rellenos de Picadillo)

Powdered-sugar-dusted pineapple carrot cake baked in a tube pan and served on a vintage ceramic plate.

Pineapple Carrot Cake

2 hr 15 minEasy

Poblano Corn Rice Casserole (Pastel de Arroz con Elote y Poblano)

Poblano Corn Rice Casserole (Pastel de Arroz con Elote y Poblano)

1 HOUR 20 MINUTESMedium

Golden Potato Kugla with crisp browned edges, bacon, and onion, served warm with sour cream and parsley.

Potato Kugla

About 2 hours 15 minutesEasy

A plate of Potato Top Stew with tender beef, carrots, celery, and overlapping golden potato slices, with the casserole in the background.

Potato Top Stew

3 hr 25 minEasy

Creamy turkey and broccoli casserole with a golden cheddar-and-breadcrumb topping in a vintage floral baking dish.

Rest of the Bird Casserole

Reuben Mushrooms

Reuben Mushrooms

Golden saffron rice with artichoke hearts, green peas, and red pimiento strips served in a vintage ceramic bowl.

Saffron Rice with Artichokes

About 1 hour 25 minutesEasy

Sliced salmon loaf on a vintage platter with peas, mashed potatoes, lemon wedges, and fresh dill.

Salmon Loaf

Four golden-brown sausage-stuffed zucchini halves on a platter with salad and garlic bread.

Sausage Stuffed Zucchini

1 hr 10 minEasy

Creamy scalloped celery and peas casserole with a golden Parmesan breadcrumb topping in a vintage oval baking dish.

Scalloped Celery and Peas

Baked Shepherd’s Pie in an oval casserole dish with browned ridged mashed potatoes, optional cheddar and parsley, and a serving spoon revealing the beef and vegetable filling.

Shepherd’s Pie

1 hr 10 minEasy

Seven golden puff pastry shells filled with creamy sherried mushrooms and garnished with chopped parsley on a vintage floral plate.

Sherried Mushrooms

Baked shrimp and artichoke casserole in sherry cream sauce with mushrooms, Parmesan, paprika, and parsley.

Shrimp & Artichoke Casserole

Snow Drop Butter Cookies prepared and ready to serve.

Snow Drop Butter Cookies

1 hr 50 minEasy

Glazed spiced chocolate zucchini Bundt cake with a walnut-studded slice, two coffee mugs, a fireplace, and skiers visible through a snowy window.

Spiced Chocolate Zucchini Cake

About 2 hours 40 minutesEasy

Plate of soft spiced oatmeal drop cookies studded with plump raisins beside a cup of coffee.

Spiced Oatmeal Drop Cookies

About 1 hour 35 minutesEasy

Hot artichoke-green chile dip baked until golden in a round ceramic casserole, served with tortilla chips, bread, and vintage floral plates.

Spicy Artichoke-Chili Dip

A creamy spinach casserole baked in a vintage floral casserole dish, with one square served on a matching plate.

Spinach Casserole

1 hr 15 minEasy

Sticky butterscotch pull-apart Bundt bread glazed with brown sugar syrup and topped with chopped pecans on a vintage serving plate.

Sticky Butterscotch Pull-Apart Bundt Bread

Beef-stuffed zucchini topped with Parmesan in a large baking dish at an outdoor family supper.

Stuffed Zucchini Bake

Four mushroom-and-tomato stuffed zucchini halves topped with browned cheddar cheese in a brown ceramic baking dish.

Stuffed Zucchini with Mushrooms

Freshly baked cinnamon rolls covered with lemon glaze in a round baking dish.

Sunrise Cinnamon Rolls

About 2 hours 15 minutesMedium

Fork-tender Sweep Steak sliced in its pan juices with onions and mushrooms in an opened foil packet.

Sweep Steak

3 hr 15 minEasy

Serving of tamale pie with seasoned ground beef, corn, black olives, and a golden cornmeal topping, finished with sour cream, salsa, and avocado.

Tamale Pie

1 hr 35 minEasy

$Baked Tex-Mex casserole topped with cheddar, beef, corn, tomatoes, and black olives, with tortillas and garnishes nearby.$

Tex-Mex Casserole

1 hr 10 minEasy

Warm chocolate Texas sheet cake with glossy chocolate frosting in a 9x13 pan, with one slice served on a vintage plate.

Texas Sheet Cake

1 hr 10 minEasy

Three-layer tres leches cake frosted with whipped cream, cinnamon and strawberries, with a slice revealing the moist sponge layers.

Tres Leches Cake (Pastel de Tres Leches)

9 HOURS 10 MINUTESMedium

Powdered-sugar-dusted triple chocolate cake in a rectangular glass baking dish with a chocolate-chip-filled slice on a red-and-white plate.

Triple Chocolate Cake

1 hr 10 minEasy

Creamy turkey enchiladas baked with cheddar and topped with diced tomato and cilantro in a vintage casserole dish.

Turkey Enchiladas

About 1 hour 30 minutesEasy

Turkey-stuffed green bell pepper half served over chunky stewed tomato sauce with a golden Parmesan topping and chopped parsley.

Turkey Stuffed Peppers

1 hr 30 minEasy

Vegan Quinoa Bean Burger

Vegan Quinoa Bean Burger

1 HOUR 15 MINUTESMedium

Veracruz-Style Fish (Pescado a la Veracruzana)

Veracruz-Style Fish (Pescado a la Veracruzana)

1 HOUR 8 MINUTESMedium

A thick square of walnut apple cake with visible apple pieces and walnuts on a vintage plate beside coffee, fresh apples, and the baking pan.

Walnut Apple Cake

1 hr 40 minEasy

Slices of wheat germ zucchini bread with finely chopped walnuts and a sesame-seed topping, served with butter beside two loaves.

Wheat Germ Zucchini Bread

2 hr 25 minEasy

Classic cinnamon zucchini bread with chopped nuts, sliced on a wooden board in a warm vintage kitchen.

Zucchini Bread

About 2 hours 30 minutesEasy

A plated serving of zucchini casserole with ground beef, tomatoes, green olives, onion, and Parmesan beside Cheesy French Bread and a simple salad.

Zucchini Casserole

1 hr 20 minEasy

Round white ceramic casserole of zucchini cheese bake topped with lightly browned sharp cheddar, with one serving removed.

Zucchini Cheese Bake

1 hr 10 minEasy