
Warm the Cream:
Heat the cream so it blends smoothly into the caramel.

Watch the sugar move from pale to deep amber; that toasted edge makes the sauce taste like real caramel. Cream smooths it into a glossy pour, and a little salt keeps the sweetness in check.
A great caramel sauce should taste like more than just melted sugar. You want that deep amber flavor, enough butter to make it luxurious, cream to soften the edges, vanilla to round it out, and salt to keep it from tasting flat. The trick is patience. Let the sugar get dark enough to taste like real caramel, but pull it before it turns bitter. Once you get the color right, everything else comes together fast.

Heat the cream so it blends smoothly into the caramel.


Boil sugar, water, and corn syrup until deep amber.

Whisk in warm cream carefully.

Add butter, vanilla, and sea salt.

Let the caramel thicken as it cools.

Watch the sugar move from pale to deep amber; that toasted edge makes the sauce taste like real caramel. Cream smooths it into a glossy pour, and a little salt keeps the sweetness in check.
About 1½ cups caramel sauce — Serving size: 1½ tablespoons

Bring The Butter Club to your table for a private dinner, cooking class, or meal at a vacation rental.
Tell Me About Your EventLoading approved reviews…
Send ingredient, instruction, or correction questions to the recipe inbox.