

Prepare the Cream Filling
Beat the softened butter and powdered sugar until very light, then add the pasteurized eggs one at a time and continue beating until the filling is pale, smooth, and fluffy.

The wafer crumbs gradually soften against a fluffy filling as this old-fashioned dessert chills. Cherries gleam through the cool layers, which cut into creamy squares the next day.
Easy to make ahead and even better after a long chill in the refrigerator, this old-fashioned layered dessert fits right in at holiday dinners, potlucks, and summer family gatherings. The vanilla wafer crumbs soften as the rich cream filling, glossy cherries, and whipped topping settle into cool, creamy squares.

I always think this tastes better the next day once the crumbs soften a little and everything settles together properly in the refrigerator overnight. Sometimes I use a smaller pan because I like the layers thicker, and I try not to rush the cream filling or it gets heavier than it ought to be.


Beat the softened butter and powdered sugar until very light, then add the pasteurized eggs one at a time and continue beating until the filling is pale, smooth, and fluffy.

Spread half of the crushed vanilla wafers across the bottom of the baking dish and press them lightly into an even layer.

Place small dollops of the cream filling across the crumbs, then spread gently to the edges without disturbing the base.

Spoon the cherry pie filling over the cream layer, then spread the whipped topping evenly over the cherries.

Sprinkle the remaining vanilla wafer crumbs evenly across the top.

Cover the dish and refrigerate at least 4 hours, preferably overnight, until the dessert is completely cold and settled enough to cut into squares.

The wafer crumbs gradually soften against a fluffy filling as this old-fashioned dessert chills. Cherries gleam through the cool layers, which cut into creamy squares the next day.
Scaling note: Ingredient quantities scale in this recipe. Review equipment capacity, batch arrangement, and cooking time when changing the yield.
12 servings — Serving size: About 1 square
Loading approved reviews…
Send ingredient, instruction, or correction questions to the recipe inbox.