
Soften the Butter:
Let the butter come to room temperature until soft but not melted.

The peanut butter goes into already fluffy butter so the finished spread stays airy rather than heavy. Honey gives it a soft sweetness, especially welcome on a warm slice of banana bread.
This is one of those butters that sounds simple, but the texture matters. If you just stir peanut butter into cold butter, it turns heavy and uneven. Whipping the butter first gives it air, then the peanut butter folds in smooth and creamy without taking over the whole thing. The honey, vanilla, and salt make it taste finished, and it is exactly the kind of thing that belongs on Oatmeal Cookie Pancakes or anything with bananas, chocolate, maple, or jelly.

Let the butter come to room temperature until soft but not melted.

Beat the butter until light, smooth, and fluffy.

Mix in creamy peanut butter until fully incorporated.


Whip in honey, powdered sugar, vanilla, and sea salt.
Transfer to a ramekin or container and chill until ready to use.

The peanut butter goes into already fluffy butter so the finished spread stays airy rather than heavy. Honey gives it a soft sweetness, especially welcome on a warm slice of banana bread.
About 1½ cups peanut butter butter — Serving size: 1 tablespoon

Bring The Butter Club to your table for a private dinner, cooking class, or meal at a vacation rental.
Tell Me About Your EventLoading approved reviews…
Send ingredient, instruction, or correction questions to the recipe inbox.