
Marinate the Mushrooms:
Season the portobello caps so they have flavor all the way through.

Roasting the portobello first keeps its polenta coating crisp when it is fried. Cool slaw and chipotle aioli make each hot, crunchy bite feel like a proper po' boy.
This is the bigger, meatier version of the vegetarian po’ boy. The portobello gives you that wide sandwich-filling bite, but the important part is getting some moisture out of the mushroom before it gets breaded. A quick roast helps concentrate the flavor, then the polenta crust gives it that crunchy exterior. Chipotle aioli and cold slaw are what make the whole sandwich work.

Season the portobello caps so they have flavor all the way through.

Roast briefly to soften the mushrooms and remove excess moisture.

Dredge in seasoned flour, soy milk, and fine polenta.

Cook until golden brown and crunchy.

Layer chipotle aioli, crispy portobello, and coleslaw on soft rolls.

Roasting the portobello first keeps its polenta coating crisp when it is fried. Cool slaw and chipotle aioli make each hot, crunchy bite feel like a proper po' boy.
4 sandwiches — Serving size: 1 po’ boy

Bring The Butter Club to your table for a private dinner, cooking class, or meal at a vacation rental.
Tell Me About Your EventLoading approved reviews…
Send ingredient, instruction, or correction questions to the recipe inbox.