
Marinate the Seitan:
Toss sliced seitan with fajita marinade.

Give the skillet enough heat for the seitan and vegetables to pick up charred edges instead of steaming. Bring it to the table sizzling, with warm tortillas ready for everyone to fill.
Fajitas need heat. The peppers and onions should get some color, the seitan should brown around the edges, and everything should hit the tortilla hot. The fajita marinade brings the seasoning, so the job here is mostly about cooking the vegetables and seitan hard enough that they taste grilled instead of steamed. Serve everything family-style with warm tortillas and let people build their own plates.

Toss sliced seitan with fajita marinade.

Grill or sear until tender and lightly charred.

Cook until hot and browned around the edges.

Toss the seitan, peppers, and onions together.
Heat the tortillas until soft and flexible.
Serve hot with fajita toppings and sides.

Give the skillet enough heat for the seitan and vegetables to pick up charred edges instead of steaming. Bring it to the table sizzling, with warm tortillas ready for everyone to fill.
4 entrée portions — Serving size: 2 fajitas

Bring The Butter Club to your table for a private dinner, cooking class, or meal at a vacation rental.
Tell Me About Your EventLoading approved reviews…
Send ingredient, instruction, or correction questions to the recipe inbox.